| Year | Name | Category |
|---|---|---|
| 1997 | Tim Lynch | Junior |
| 1996 | Pat Carter | Mens |
| 1996 | David Lawrence | Senior |
| 1996 | Sam O'Dell | Junior |
| 1995 | Pat Carter | Mens |
| 1995 | Charles Persinger | Senior |
| 1995 | Kirk Satterfield | Junior |
| 1994 | Jack Forbes | Senior |
| 1994 | Steve Fox | Mens |
| 1994 | Michael B. Veres | Junior |
| 1993 | Jamie T. Conrad | Junior |
| 1993 | Harold Payne | Mens |
| 1992 | Bradley H. Greenstein | Junior |
| 1992 | Eric Shaffer | Mens |
| 1991 | Pat Carter | Mens |
| 1991 | Bradley H. Greenstein | Junior |
| 1990 | Scott Gilmore | Mens |
| 1990 | Stephanie Sparks | Junior |
| 1989 | Pat Carter | Mens |
| 1988 | Steve Fox | Mens |
| 1987 | Harold Payne | Mens |
| 1986 | Harold Payne | Mens |